Description

My basic trading philosophy can be summed up by one simple quote:

"Trade the ticker, not the company" - Nate Michaud


Wednesday, October 22, 2014

Lessons From My $290,000 $LAKE Loss

I realize I'm getting a bit behind on blog posts, and I know I still owe many of you a breakdown of how I made the spreadsheets that I mentioned in my Vegas presentation this year! However, after an unplanned wild two weeks of trading that took up most of my time and energy, I decided that a post about my losses was a much higher priority.

Before we get into some of the specific mistakes I made with LAKE, we need to examine the underlying problem. This underlying problem was present in my trading all summer, ever since I started transitioning over to listed stocks. What was this problem? My unwillingness to cut losses when I shorted momentum runners too early. Just take a look at these two tweets of mine from July:



As far back as July, I knew that I was playing with fire. I even went so far as to predict that my stubbornness would badly burn me eventually. Yet despite knowing this, I refused to make a change. I'm not sure whether it was due to pride, fear of exiting at the top of a spike, or perhaps just the thrill of turning a loser into a winner. Whatever it was, the problem only got worse. Here are a couple of trades from my profitly that don't look too bad on paper, but there was far more to the story:


While on paper this looks like a solid GPRO gain, the reality is that at one point I was down over $50,000 on the trade. 


Similar to GPRO, this RADA loss doesn't look like anything too unusual. However, the reality is that at one point I was down over $90,000 on this trade.

These are just two examples, but I know there were far more uncomfortable situations that I held through. In fact, RADA might have been one of the only ones that didn't turn out to be a profit for me. While in the back of my mind I kept thinking, "Eventually this won't work out," my bad habit kept being rewarded with narrow escapes and sometimes even solid profits. I knew my trading style was broken, but the results never showed it. In fact, I was even rewarded with my most profitable trading month ever in September! I continued to play larger and larger as the gains poured in, refusing to address the underlying issue. Then LAKE came along, and the wheels came off. 

My LAKE trade started off well enough; I had shorted 10,000 shares at about a $9.90 average, and I was pleased with the price action. It appeared to be fading, and I believed I would be able to cover in the low $9s or high $8s. Below, you can see the complete intraday chart:


As I was watching LAKE attempt to crack the low of the day, I was feeling VERY good about my short. I was already up over $3000; it was just a question of when to take profits. Then, a press release came out. I don't remember the specifics. All I remember is that very quickly my $3000+ gain was back to break-even. This upset me - I wanted those profits! I also didn't want to cover into the top of a spike, I was hoping that the spike would quickly top out and we'd get back to the weak price action that I had just seen. However, as the day wore on, it became clear that LAKE was not going to slow down. My one-time profitable position was now down badly, so I figured I'd just go for a ride, like I had so many times before the last few months. I could always average up, and how bad could it get? At the close of the day, I was down roughly $16,000 unrealized. 

The next morning LAKE was gapping up, and although I was annoyed, I welcomed the chance to add more size higher and get my average up. I knew I had gotten stubborn with my original position. When adding to a loser, I always tell myself not to get stubborn with the adds too. For whatever reason, I failed to heed my own advice in this case. 30 minutes into the day, I was already trying to average up into the spike to $13. There was a brief pullback, but then the stock ripped right back. I now had 20,000 shares from an $11.50ish average, and I failed to downsize when my mid-$13s risk level broke:


At this point, I was getting uncomfortable; but I still had room to add, and I was going to use it! I just had to be more careful. LAKE started to look heavy to me as the $16 area topped, so I threw in another add. This time, I believe it was roughly 20,000 shares in the high $15s, bringing my total position to 40,000 shares. LAKE tested $15 a few times, and I kept waiting and praying for it to break down, yet the snap never came. After holding $15 for a second time, LAKE ripped through the $16 resistance area, which I AGAIN failed to cover into. Suddenly, the stock was over $18, and I was sitting on my worst unrealized loss ever. 

A couple of hours of consolidation later, and I still had all my shares. LAKE had pulled back to $16, but it had failed to break down any further. I could have downsized into this pullback, but I remained stubborn. I wanted a bigger move so that my damage would be less! I was thinking about my money, not about what the chart was telling me. When LAKE perked back through $17, that's when I began to get scared. I realized how out of control the loss could get if I stayed stubborn and LAKE kept ripping into the afternoon. So I took off all my adds into the strength, somewhere around $18. Once the adds were covered, the damage JUST from the adds was roughly $100,000. I was left sitting with my 10,000 shares from $9.90, which was still down another unrealized $80,000. I had opened myself up to losses I had never experienced before because of the massive size I forced myself to play to try to fix a bad situation.

While financially this wasn't crippling to my account, it was mentally disastrous for me. Taking the size off did allow me to attack again the next morning, and I was bound and determined to NAIL it with size to make back my losses, and then some:


I actually had a decent short right out of the gate, 25,000 shares at $20.50. Within 30 minutes, I was up well over $50,000 unrealized. But it wasn't good enough. I didn't lock these gains in, rather, sitting on my short all day trying to mentally will it into breaking down. The snap never came, and my one-time $50,000+ unrealized profit turned into less than a $10,000 gain by the time I locked it in. The next day, I tried again: 


All morning I fought the stock with large positions, making emotional shorts into weakness and covers into strength. I probably was playing 20,000-30,000 share positions at a time, all the while still holding my original 10,000 shares from $9.90. Mentally, I was toast. I had gotten so far away from my typical trading that what I was doing now was hardly recognizable. The results showed that, I tacked on an additional $75,000+ in losses. The one silver lining in all of this was that I cut ALL of my losses once LAKE began to break out past $22.50ish. Had I held through this spike, my losses would have probably doubled. However, the damage was done. My $9.90 position became a realized $120,000 loss. 

The next day, LAKE finally had a meaningful pullback. But at this point I was so mentally defeated and exhausted, I think I only played 5000 shares and made a couple dollars per share on the trade. The end result of all of my LAKE trading came out to $290,000 in damage:


For all of the times my stubborn trades had worked out, LAKE gave all those profits back, and then some. The amazing thing about trading is that you can be right (or get lucky) 99 times out of 100, but it only takes that one time to wipe you out. Staying stubborn in losses is the easiest way to open yourself up to a HUGE level of risk, and I must force myself into discipline to make sure this NEVER happens again. Protecting your account is far more important that avoiding a small loss for the sake of your pride.

My stubbornness affected me elsewhere too. I was trading size on other positions, in setups I normally wouldn't even play. I lost just under $40,000 on an impulsive SIMH long (which I failed to cut the loss quickly on), and after making back some of my losses on a well-timed short on VSR, I gave back all of the gains on yet another stubborn loss on IBIO. 

October will go down in the books as my first losing month since I started trading full time, and I FULLY deserve it. While I could stick around and battle the next two weeks, I must not lose sight of the big picture. 2014 has been an INCREDIBLE year for me so far, and even after this month of losses I am still up over one million dollars for the year. To push for a break-even or better month when I know I'm not mentally right would do nothing more than put more of those gains in jeopardy, and I refuse to do that. So I will take a much needed break from trading, my first vacation in quite awhile, and I will come back refreshed in November for a fresh start! 

26 comments:

  1. Tim, awesome blog and congrats for this incredible year. Once again, thanks for teaching and sharing. Enjoy ur time off, with a clear mind it'll be a walk in the park again. Looking forward for ur next webinar, regards.

    R.O.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Tim,

    Thank you for sharing, it really helped me understand how to trade with a clear mind. I did want to know in this case how would you cut looses intelligently being that you might come emotionally attached to the trade? In hindsight how can you distance yourself from unrealized proftis and pick the best choice. Enjoy your time off, and to many more green months.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Tim, thanks for the insights. Very well written story about a "problem" I think a lot of us battle. I know it's my biggest demon. Enjoy your well earned time off!

    ReplyDelete
  4. I'm reminded of the following quote after reading this post, and whenever dealing with trading losses in general:

    “You can be mad as a mad dog at the way things went. You could swear, curse the fates, but when it comes to the end, you have to let go.” - Benjamin Button, "The Curious Case of Benjamin Button"

    Thanks for sharing these lessons with everyone, Tim. It says a lot about your character when you open about trades that don't work out for you - it shows that you've taken your hits too, and that the markets can slap even the best of us in the face from time to time.

    By understanding the reasons behind your LAKE loss, you will be all the better moving forward. Your decision to take a break is wise - come back fresh and with a renewed sense of perspective. Enjoy the time off.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Great post Tim. I too had a large loss in LAKE. Like you I was using way too much size and way too much risk. I wrote a blog post about it as well.
    http://www.welcometothegutter.com/falling-off-the-mountain/

    ReplyDelete
  6. Very very smart of you to take a break. I applaud you for a wise decision. It's much better to trade later with clarity than it is to trade "missed opportunities" in a hasty, sloppy manner. You're still great, but the market is greater. Stay humble!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Thank you for sharing this experience, which we can learn from.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Tim, yet another golden post. This one reminded me of my own 'Battle' with SCTY short, same problems - Stubborn, Size, even worse, I leveraged.

    I got reminded of this quote after reading your blog and after I took similar hit on SCTY short. Must be helpful for fellow traders:

    Ed Seykota Quote: “If you can’t take a small loss, sooner or later you will take the mother of all losses.”

    I am thinking on 'how' I can enforce this discipline systematically so there is no emotional element involved. I remember from Nate's DVD that he recommends having an "Oh Shit" threshold.

    As always, I am very thankful for your posts, please keep them coming. I also request you to do a post on sizing in and out. How do you decide how much to size in. At what point you take partial profits versus full profits. What triggers a decision to size in when it starts to go for you. Thanks.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Thanks for sharing! As always, really appreciate your posts and learning a lot. Everyone is susceptible to going "on tilt." It'd be interesting if you can share what processes/techniques you put in place to avoid tilting in the future. Enjoy your break!

    ReplyDelete
  10. Great Blog thanks for helping us all well done.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Tim you're wise beyond your years, thank you for being willing to share this difficult experience.

    Your success is inspiring and has contributed to my desire to be a trader. I'm fresh and had a rough first week of actual trading (after about 6 weeks of dastrader pro demos, studying everything I can find, Nate's DVD, following IU chat every day, etc.) The second I started trading real money I started experiencing my stupid side, often using hope as my strategy to get a stock to go back where I need it to.

    Your insights have been really helpful. Resources like this blog make me determined to still be around in 6 months. I really hope we'll be able to continue to hear from you. Forget October, November will be awesome!

    ReplyDelete
  12. A profitably trader is a trader who is consistent in cutting loses quickly and locking in profits period end of story and I think Tim will agree with me on that . Tim didn't write this post for sympathy hes trying to keep us from blowing up or accounts he knows we are all not Millionaires here.

    We as traders must first learn how to loses in this business before we can be successful traders. Loses are a guaranty in this game but the key is learning how to manage them. How do you do that you might ask by cutting loses quickly and locking in profits before they become unrealized loses and the trade has gone against you.

    Tim is telling us that the market does care about who you are or where you come or how big your bank account is or how smart you might think you are or how many technical indators your might use on your sufisticated trading platform the market is there for only one thing and that is to make money by any means necessary and means taking your money and it will outlast any bank account no matter how large or small it may be.

    Plan the trade and trade the plan is how Tim became a consistent profitably trader and when he gets back from vacation I'm sure he go back to his roots.

    Learn Traders it's about managing loses in this game in order to be successful not how much money I can make! The money will come if you cut loses intelligently and quick

    Thanks Tim you are the real deal my friend

    ReplyDelete
  13. Thanks again Tim for that lesson! Have a great vaca!

    ReplyDelete
  14. Thank Tim! Met you in Vegas- respect posts like these most of all. Can you comment on the basics you looking to get back to in November? Aside from the obvious.

    ReplyDelete
  15. HOW ON EARTH do you lose quarter of a $$ million shorting a stock that (at the right time) is clearly going down????

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. because at the wrong time, it was clearly going up!!... he even said that he shorted early and wasn't helped by the unplanned PR! did you read the original post at all? :-/

      Delete
  16. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  17. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Great post Tim. It's pretty amazing how many of us go through these very same feelings and struggles without your ability to recognize them in time. Definite maturity here.

    ReplyDelete
  19. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  20. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Question-- when shorting a stock and it reverses, meaning it goes up do i have to pay back the broker right away, end of day or can i hold it until it comes back or goes down how does that shorting all work money wise please

    ReplyDelete
  22. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  23. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Hi Tim,

    You often talk about not liking to hold a stock over night into the next day. Can you buy and sell stocks over night? or can you only buy and sell during trading hours?

    Regards

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Listed stocks end extended hours trading at 8:00 pm eastern. Overnight, there is no ability to trade them

      Delete